| Name | Party | Ward | End of Term |
|---|
| Lissie Sharp | Labour Party | Alston Moor | 2023 |
| Michael Hanley | Labour Party | Alston Moor | 2023 |
| Karen Greenwood | Independent / Other | Appleby (Appleby) | 2023 |
| Andrew Connell | Liberal Democrats | Appleby (Bongate) | 2023 |
| Laura Harker | Liberal Democrats | Askham | 2023 |
| Graham Simpkins | Liberal Democrats | Brough | 2023 |
| Joan Raine | Conservative and Unionist | Crosby Ravensworth | 2023 |
| Judith Derbyshire | Liberal Democrats | Dacre | 2023 |
| Ian Chambers | Conservative and Unionist | Eamont | 2023 |
| Debra Wicks | Conservative and Unionist | Greystoke | 2023 |
| Robin Orchard | Conservative and Unionist | Hartside | 2023 |
| Elaine Martin | Conservative and Unionist | Hesket | 2023 |
| David Ryland | Independent / Other | Hesket | 2023 |
| Phil Dew | Conservative and Unionist | Kirkby Stephen | 2023 |
| Sandy Lancaster | Independent / Other | Kirkby Stephen | 2023 |
| Henry Sawrey-Cookson | Independent / Other | Kirkby Thore | 2023 |
| Mary Robinson | Independent / Other | Kirkoswald | 2023 |
| Douglas Banks | Independent / Other | Langwathby | 2023 |
| Gordon Nicolson OBE | Conservative and Unionist | Lazonby | 2023 |
| Allan Armstrong | Conservative and Unionist | Long Marton | 2023 |
| Michael Tonkin | Independent / Other | Morland | 2023 |
| Adrian Todd | Conservative and Unionist | Orton With Tebay | 2023 |
| Doug Lawson | Green Party (E&W) | Penrith Carleton | 2023 |
| John Charles Lynch | Conservative and Unionist | Penrith East | 2023 |
| Michael Denis Eyles | Liberal Democrats | Penrith East | 2023 |
| Mark Rudhall | Liberal Democrats | Penrith North | 2023 |
| Ali Ross | Green Party (E&W) | Penrith North | 2023 |
| Deb Holden | Liberal Democrats | Penrith North | 2023 |
| Peter Baker | Liberal Democrats | Penrith Pategill | 2023 |
| Paul Connor | Independent / Other | Penrith South | 2023 |
| Margaret Clark | Independent / Other | Penrith South | 2023 |
| John George Thompson | Conservative and Unionist | Penrith West | 2023 |
| Virginia Taylor | Liberal Democrats | Penrith West | 2023 |
| Angela Meadowcroft | Conservative and Unionist | Ravenstonedale | 2023 |
| John Owen MBE | Conservative and Unionist | Shap | 2023 |
| Kevin Beaty | Conservative and Unionist | Skelton | 2023 |
| Darrell Smith | Liberal Democrats | Ullswater | 2023 |
| William Patterson | Independent / Other | Warcop | 2023 |