| Name | Party | Ward | End of Term |
|---|
| Nadean Moses | Conservative and Unionist Party | Banstead Village | 05-05-2022 |
| Sam Walsh | Conservative and Unionist Party | Banstead Village | 04-05-2023 |
| Eddy Humphreys | Conservative and Unionist Party | Banstead Village | 07-05-2020 |
| Simon Parnall | Conservative and Unionist Party | Chipstead, Kingswood & Woodmansterne | 07-05-2020 |
| Tim Archer | Conservative and Unionist Party | Chipstead, Kingswood & Woodmansterne | 05-05-2022 |
| Caroline Neame | Conservative and Unionist Party | Chipstead, Kingswood & Woodmansterne | 04-05-2023 |
| Susan Fenton | Green Party | Earlswood & Whitebushes | 04-05-2023 |
| Ruth Ritter | Green Party | Earlswood & Whitebushes | 07-05-2020 |
| Hal Brown | Green Party | Earlswood & Whitebushes | 05-05-2022 |
| Mark Brunt | Conservative and Unionist Party | Hooley, Merstham and Netherne | 04-05-2023 |
| Keith Foreman | Conservative and Unionist Party | Hooley, Merstham and Netherne | 07-05-2020 |
| Frank Kelly | Conservative and Unionist Party | Hooley, Merstham and Netherne | 05-05-2022 |
| Christian Stevens | Conservative and Unionist Party | Horley Central & South | 04-05-2023 |
| Jerry Hudson | Conservative and Unionist Party | Horley Central & South | 07-05-2020 |
| Andy Lynch | Conservative and Unionist Party | Horley Central & South | 05-05-2022 |
| Graham Knight | Conservative and Unionist Party | Horley East & Salfords | 05-05-2022 |
| Tony Schofield | Conservative and Unionist Party | Horley East & Salfords | 04-05-2023 |
| Derek Allcard | Conservative and Unionist Party | Horley East & Salfords | 07-05-2020 |
| Giorgio Buttironi | Conservative and Unionist Party | Horley West & Sidlow | 05-05-2022 |
| Alex Horwood | Conservative and Unionist Party | Horley West & Sidlow | 04-05-2023 |
| Richard Biggs | Conservative and Unionist Party | Horley West & Sidlow | 07-05-2020 |
| Rod Ashford | Conservative and Unionist Party | Lower Kingswood, Tadworth & Walton | 07-05-2020 |
| Jamie Paul | Conservative and Unionist Party | Lower Kingswood, Tadworth & Walton | 05-05-2022 |
| Rachel Turner | Conservative and Unionist Party | Lower Kingswood, Tadworth & Walton | 04-05-2023 |
| Jane Philpott | Liberal Democrats | Meadvale & St John’s | 04-05-2023 |
| David Ross | Liberal Democrats | Meadvale & St John’s | 07-05-2020 |
| Stephen Kulka | Liberal Democrats | Meadvale & St John’s | 05-05-2022 |
| Ross Feeney | Nork Residents' Association | Nork | 04-05-2023 |
| Peter Harp | Nork Residents' Association | Nork | 07-05-2020 |
| Gemma Adamson | Nork Residents' Association | Nork | 05-05-2022 |
| Jonathan Essex | Green Party | Redhill East | 04-05-2023 |
| Stephen McKenna | Green Party | Redhill East | 07-05-2020 |
| Sue Sinden | Green Party | Redhill East | 05-05-2022 |
| Rich Michalowski | Conservative and Unionist Party | Redhill West & Wray Common | 05-05-2022 |
| Kanika Sachdeva | Conservative and Unionist Party | Redhill West & Wray Common | 04-05-2023 |
| Natalie Bramhall | Conservative and Unionist Party | Redhill West & Wray Common | 07-05-2020 |
| Michael Blacker | Conservative and Unionist Party | Reigate | 05-05-2022 |
| Christopher Whinney | Independent | Reigate | 04-05-2023 |
| Rosemary Absalom | Conservative and Unionist Party | Reigate | 07-05-2020 |
| James King | Conservative and Unionist Party | South Park & Woodhatch | 07-05-2020 |
| Victor Lewanski | Conservative and Unionist Party | South Park & Woodhatch | 05-05-2022 |
| Simon Rickman | Conservative and Unionist Party | South Park & Woodhatch | 04-05-2023 |
| Nick Harrison | Tattenhams & Preston Residents | Tattenham Corner & Preston | 04-05-2023 |
| Jill Bray | Tattenhams & Preston Residents | Tattenham Corner & Preston | 07-05-2020 |
| Bob Harper | Tattenhams & Preston Residents | Tattenham Corner & Preston | 05-05-2022 |