| Name | Party | Ward | End of Term |
|---|
| Steve Mason | Liberal Democrats | Amotherby | 2023 |
| Jim Bailey | Conservative and Unionist | Ampleforth | 2023 |
| John Clark | The Liberal Party | Cropton | 2023 |
| Janet Frank | Independent / Other | Dales | 2023 |
| Michael Cleary | Conservative and Unionist | Derwent | 2023 |
| Sue Graham | Conservative and Unionist | Derwent | 2023 |
| Snowy Windress | Independent / Other | Helmsley | 2023 |
| Steve Arnold | Independent / Other | Helmsley | 2023 |
| Claire Docwra | Conservative and Unionist | Hovingham | 2023 |
| Tony Riby | Independent / Other | Kirkbymoorside | 2023 |
| David Cussons | Independent / Other | Kirkbymoorside | 2023 |
| Paul Andrews | Independent / Other | Malton | 2023 |
| Angela Kirkham-Raine | Independent / Other | Malton | 2023 |
| Lindsay Burr | Independent / Other | Malton | 2023 |
| Ray King | Conservative and Unionist | Norton East | 2023 |
| Keane Duncan | Conservative and Unionist | Norton East | 2023 |
| Di Keal | Liberal Democrats | Norton West | 2023 |
| John Mackenzie | Conservative and Unionist | Norton West | 2023 |
| Joy Andrews | The Liberal Party | Pickering East | 2023 |
| Clive Wass | The Liberal Party | Pickering East | 2023 |
| Mike Potter | The Liberal Party | Pickering West | 2023 |
| Carrie Brackstone | The Liberal Party | Pickering West | 2023 |
| Nathan Garbutt Moore | Conservative and Unionist | Rillington | 2023 |
| Caroline Goodrick | Conservative and Unionist | Ryedale South West | 2023 |
| John Raper | Independent / Other | Sherburn | 2023 |
| Eric Hope | Independent / Other | Sheriff Hutton | 2023 |
| Simon Thackray | Independent / Other | Sinnington | 2023 |
| Chris Delaney | Conservative and Unionist | Thornton Dale | 2023 |
| Will Oxley | Conservative and Unionist | Thornton Dale | 2023 |
| Tracie Middleton | Conservative and Unionist | Wolds | 2023 |